Kathy notices Harper's pin—Beginners 1—and questions why the strongest student would join a beginner section at their town academy. When she accuses him of stalking, Harper denies it with unconvincing words, yet continues following her regardless. His contradictions pile up: a wealthy family who takes the bus, enrollment at MEA despite claiming no intention to study, suspicious behavior that suggests hidden motives. As Harper persistently trails her through the corridors, Kathy confronts the painful truth of their past. She admits forgiveness came long ago, but forgetting remains impossible. The distinction cuts deep—Harper can be pardoned for his actions, yet the memory of what he did will haunt her forever. She walks away, leaving him alone with the weight of her words and the chasm between absolution and moving forward.